Skip to content 
Before you even start collecting data or analysing customers, you need to know why you’re doing segmentation, how long you expect it to take, and how you’ll measure its success.
Clear expectations, goals and ambitions are the difference between a segmentation you can actually act on, and a very expensive exercise in data rearrangement. Without them, you’re like a dog chasing a car – it’s all very exciting, but what are you going to do when you reach your goal?
The most successful segmentation projects start with crystal-clear objectives that guide every decision throughout the process. Let’s explore the tools and frameworks that ensure your segmentation delivers real business value.
Why goal-setting makes or breaks segmentation success
Too many segmentation projects fail not because of poor methodology or inadequate data, but because teams never clearly defined what success looks like. Without clear goals, you end up with:
- Analysis paralysis: Endless exploration of data without clear direction
- Misaligned expectations: Different stakeholders expecting different outcomes
- Unusable insights: Segments that are interesting but not actionable
- Poor adoption: Teams unsure how to apply the segmentation to their work
- Wasted resources: Time and money spent without measurable return
Setting clear goals upfront prevents these pitfalls and ensures your segmentation becomes a powerful strategic tool rather than an expensive report that sits on a shelf.
Framework 1: The core question method
The most effective way to clarify your segmentation goals is to define one overarching question that your segmentation must answer. This core question becomes your north star, guiding all subsequent decisions about methodology, data collection, and analysis.
Examples of strong core questions:
Strategic repositioning: “How can we reposition our brand to better compete against [specific competitor] in the [specific category] market?”
Growth strategy: “Which customer segments represent our biggest untapped growth opportunities in the next 3 years?”
Product innovation: “What unmet customer needs should drive our new product development roadmap?”
Market entry: “How should we approach the [specific market/geography] to maximize our chances of successful entry?”
Customer experience: “How can we personalise our customer experience to increase retention and lifetime value?”
What makes a good core question:
- Specific enough to guide decision-making
- Broad enough to generate actionable insights
- Aligned with business priorities and timelines
- Measurable in terms of success criteria
- Actionable – something your organisation can actually do something about
Framework 2: The issue tree approach
Once you have your core question, create an issue tree that breaks it down into all the specific questions your segmentation needs to answer. This comprehensive list acts like a checklist and keeps everyone on track throughout the project.
Building Your Issue Tree:
Level 1: Your core question Level 2: The main categories of insight needed Level 3: Specific questions within each category Level 4: Detailed sub-questions that inform analysis
Example issue tree: "How can we accelerate growth in our customer base?"
Customer understanding
- Who are our most valuable customers and why?
- What drives customer satisfaction and loyalty?
- Which customers are at risk of churning and why?
Market opportunity
- Which segments are undeserved by current competitors?
- What unmet needs exist in our target market?
- How is the competitive landscape changing?
Capability assessment
- Which segments align best with our current capabilities?
- What capabilities would we need to serve new segments?
- How can we differentiate from competitors?
Activation strategy
- How should we prioritise segments for targeting?
- What messages and channels work best for each segment?
- How will we measure success and ROI?
Benefits of the issue tree:
- Comprehensive coverage: Ensures you don’t miss important areas
- Stakeholder alignment: Gets everyone agreeing on scope upfront
- Progress tracking: Provides clear milestones throughout the project
- Quality control: Helps evaluate whether insights answer the original questions
Matching ambition to approach: Project scope examples
Different segmentation goals require different approaches, timelines, and resources. Here are examples of how scope affects project design:
Strategic transformation project
Example: A multinational personal care company wanted to change their entire customer focus from category-use to human-emotion (from “how do they use our products” to “how do our products make them feel”).
Core question: “How can we reposition our entire brand portfolio around emotional benefits rather than functional features?”
Scope:
- Global market research across multiple countries
- Deep emotional and psychological profiling
- Brand architecture implications
- Long-term strategic planning (3-5 years)
Timeline: 12-18 months Investment: High Expected ROI: Fundamental business transformation
Tactical optimisation project
Example: A company with a niche range of frozen low-calorie meals needed insights for a minor product rebranding.
Core Question: “How should we reposition our low-calorie meal range to increase market share in the health-conscious segment?”
Scope:
- Focused category research
- Specific product positioning
- Tactical marketing implications
- Short-term optimisation (6-12 months)
Timeline: 3-6 months Investment: Moderate Expected ROI: Improved product performance
Both were valid uses of segmentation, but the ambitions were hugely different, requiring tailored approaches to match.
Tool 1: The segmentation brief template
Use this template to capture your goals clearly:
Business context
- What business challenge are you trying to solve?
- What decisions will this segmentation inform?
- What’s the expected timeline for implementation?
Core question
- What is the one main question this segmentation must answer?
Success criteria
- How will you measure if the segmentation is successful?
- What business metrics should improve as a result?
- What ROI do you expect?
Scope and constraints
- Which customers/markets are in scope?
- What resources and timeline are available?
- What limitations should we be aware of?
Stakeholder alignment
- Who will use the segmentation and how?
- What are their specific needs and requirements?
- How will adoption be measured?
Tool 2: The KPI framework
Define clear, measurable outcomes that your segmentation should enable:
Business impact KPIs
- Revenue growth from target segments
- Market share improvement in key categories
- Customer acquisition cost reduction
- Customer lifetime value increase
- Conversion rate improvements
Operational KPIs
- Campaign performance improvements
- Targeting accuracy increases
- Customer satisfaction scores
- Employee confidence in customer understanding
- Speed of decision-making
Usage KPIs
- Number of teams actively using segmentation
- Frequency of segmentation application
- Quality of segmentation-informed decisions
- Integration with existing business processes
Framework 3: The ambition ladder
Different levels of ambition require different approaches:
Level 1: Optimisation
Goal: Improve existing processes and performance Timeframe: 6-12 months Example: Better targeting of current campaigns
Level 2: Innovation
Goal: Create new products, services, or approaches Timeframe: 1-2 years Example: Develop new product lines for underserved segments
Level 3: Transformation
Goal: Fundamental change in business strategy or model Timeframe: 2-5 years Example: Complete repositioning of brand portfolio
Choose your level based on your organisation’s readiness for change and available resources.
Common goal-setting mistakes to avoid
Mistake 1: Multiple competing objectives Don’t try to solve every business challenge with one segmentation. Focus on your most important priority.
Mistake 2: Vague success criteria “Better understanding customers” isn’t measurable. Define specific metrics and targets.
Mistake 3: Unrealistic timelines Strategic segmentations take time. Don’t compromise quality for speed.
Mistake 4: Insufficient stakeholder buy-in Get agreement on goals before starting, not after presenting results.
Mistake 5: Ignoring implementation reality Consider your organisation’s ability to act on insights when setting goals.
Getting stakeholder alignment
Use these techniques to ensure everyone is aligned on goals:
Workshop sessions: Bring key stakeholders together to define objectives collaboratively
Priority voting: Have stakeholders rank potential objectives to identify the most important ones
Success scenarios: Ask stakeholders to describe what success would look like in concrete terms
Resource reality check: Ensure goals match available time, budget, and capabilities
Implementation planning: Discuss how insights will be used before starting the project
Preparing for success
Remember that more ambitious segmentations can inform your company’s strategy for the next 4-7 years. You may update numbers or deepen your understanding of segments over time, but the basic framework will stay.
You also want to use your segmentation as soon as it’s created. Understanding your current situation means you can identify your strengths and weaknesses and prepare for when the segments arrive, maximising the window of opportunity to achieve ROI.
Next steps: From goals to action
Once you have clear goals:
- Validate with stakeholders – ensure everyone understands and agrees
- Choose your methodology – match your approach to your ambition level
- Plan your timeline – work backwards from when you need insights
- Allocate resources – ensure adequate budget and team capacity
- Set up measurement – establish baseline metrics and tracking systems
Clear goals don’t just improve your segmentation – they dramatically increase the likelihood that your insights will drive real business results.
Without clear ambition, even the most sophisticated segmentation will fail to deliver value. With the right goals and frameworks, segmentation becomes a powerful engine for strategic growth.
Next in our series: We’ll explore how to choose the right data for your segmentation – from demographics and behaviours to attitudes and needs – and create segments that deliver actionable insights for your business.